New York City FC vs New York Red Bulls: Red Bulls' Trophy Cabinet Dwarfs NYCFC

Red Bulls Dominate the Hardware

Red Bulls hold a clear edge in silverware. They claim 2 MLS Cup titles. New York City FC sits at 0.

Supporters' Shield tells a bigger story. Red Bulls grabbed 4. NYCFC managed just 1.

U.S. Open Cup adds to it. Red Bulls have 1. NYCFC has none.

Head to Head Record Favors Red Bulls

In all-time wins, Red Bulls lead with 12. New York City FC trails at 8.

This gap shows in New York City FC vs New York Red Bulls stats. Red Bulls win more often.

Every matchup feels tight. But history leans Bull-side.

Trophy Gap Fuels the Rivalry

Red Bulls' 4 Shields mock NYCFC's lone one. That stings in a city derby.

No MLS Cups for NYCFC hurts most. Red Bulls celebrate 2 times.

• Red Bulls: 2 MLS Cups, 4 Shields, 1 Open Cup
• NYCFC: 1 Shield, zeros elsewhere

Historical Matchups Breed Bad Blood

Head to Head record sits at 8-12. Red Bulls edge it.

These historical matchups pack tension. Trophies make Red Bulls the big brother.

NYCFC chases. Red Bulls hold the hardware.

Rivalry Rooted in Red Bulls' Edge

Red Bulls own the trophies. NYCFC plays catch-up.

Wins tilt Bull-way too. This derby stays heated.